Just a thought Jon, how about switching this site over to look like the vbulletin AWF site? It would serve three functions, you would see how it works, members from AWF could see if they liked the look and feel, and as a bonus you would get more Google attention on the Mind Tavern Site, might give it a Boost!
Hey, that's a clever idea! I am curious about how it would look myself! I would only do it as an experiment though, since I prefer this look to the AWF look. But the great thing about Xenforo is that if I gave a couple of different themes, people could choose their own. i think I know which one you would prefer!
Edit: Just seen that the theme I linked to before is only for an earlier version of Xenforo. Drat! Will have a look around to see if there is anything else out there.